Healthy Halloween?

I love Halloween. We have our lighted skeletons in the yard and all of our pumpkins are purchased, waiting to be carved later this week. (We can’t carve them any earlier, we don’t want the design to cave in or the pumpkin to rot too soon!) And even though we have no children yet, we really enjoy spending the night at home and handing candy out to all the trick-or-treaters that come to the door. We are especially fond of little princesses and tiny superheros. Teenagers in ‘Scream’ masks? Not as much.

I always loved Halloween as a kid. I was quite devastated to be “too old” to trick-or-treat, but I also understood that it was just weird and creepy. I looked forward to dressing up (my mom made us great costumes) and gathering my loot before heading to the Halloween party at the school. And when I got home I would dump out my bag of goodies and sort it all, saving my favorites until the very end and pawning off the “yucky” stuff to people who wanted it. (For me, it was the Bit O’Honey and Smarties. And pennies… why did people give kids pennies? I preferred toothbrushes from dentists homes over the dumb pennies.)

So that’s part of the reason I always hate reading those articles that pop up at this time of year about keeping Halloween healthier. Yes, I am a health nut. I deprive myself of sweets and fats and grease and about every other supposedly “decadent” thing in this world. I live in fear of being unhealthy and out of shape. But I adamantly refuse to play the game these articles recommend because I also remember what a thrill Halloween was for me as a kid.

The articles that recommend only giving out candy that you dislike so you don’t snack, or handing out prizes like pencils and stickers… well, that’s never going to happen in my house. I know I don’t need all that candy around tempting me. And for the most part I am really good at ignoring it. What I can’t ignore is the pangs of guilt for even considering giving out something that isn’t tasty.

I know that some parents are probably dreading the sugar-high their kids may have for days after. And it does make me sad to see so many really chubby kids walking around in this world now. But for one night, I’m doing my part to contribute to that in the form of Snickers, Twix, Milky Way, M&M’s and other delicious forms of sugar.

PS – Check out the giveaway on Bethany’s site for uber-cute Halloween bags. I would be tempted to enter, but I think they should go to people who actually have little tykes in need of trick-or-treat bags!

Advertisement

Leave a Comment to “Healthy Halloween?”

  1. Jill, thanks for the shout-out! And I agree with you about Halloween. I do hand out non-candy things at Halloween, like stickers and mini containers of play-dough and pencils, but I hand it out WITH the good candy. So much of the innocence of childhood is gone…let’s not take the pleasure of a sugar rush once or twice a year away too!

    Also, just thought I’d share my two cents—or rather, my mom’s two cents—about how much candy to let your kids have. My mom always made us bring all the candy home and sorted through it with us. My brother and I compared our hauls and traded the stuff we didn’t like. My mom would take about half the candy and put it away, with us knowing begging wouldn’t get us that candy. Then she basically let us eat whatever we wanted! If we ate it all in one night, it was gone and she didn’t have to listen to us whining about wanting more candy for days to come! Our teeth weren’t being assaulted with sugar for a solid week! And, after we did that once or twice and were totally sick, we stopped gorging ourselves and started rationing out the candy to ourselves in a reasonable way. She did the same thing at Easter.

  2. My #1 rule is to give out candy that I like. I think everyone should do that. And I don’t actually like candy in large quantities, so I know I won’t be tempted to overdo it.

    And, also, trick-or-treating could be the most exercise some of these kids get all year. Let us support their walking door-to-door.

    Do you dress up? I have a really hard time having the desire to dress up.

  3. Oh, and I love your new color and quote! Do you know the extra inside jokiness of that quote in that movie? The guy who produced Legally Blonde also produced Josie and the Pussycats (a seriously underrated movie, in my opinion). In one of the scenes at the nail salon, one of the women is reading a magazine with Rachael Leigh Cook, Tara Reid, and Rosario Dawson (actresses who starred in JatP) on the cover. AND…in Josie and the Pussycats, a brainwashed teenage consumer utters the line, “You guys! Orange…is the new pink!”

    Oh my WORD, I am such a total movie geek. :-)

  4. Bethany: Your mom sounds like a wise woman. That is a great philosophy with the candy. I think if you make the candy off limits it will just drive the kids more batty trying to get it.

    I didn’t know that Josie & the Pussycats reference, but it totally seems like something I should know! I’m a little embarrassed to admit this, but I actually have the soundtrack for Josie & the Pussycats! I’m right there with you on thinking it’s underrated! I love when you share these factoids with me!

    Cardine: I don’t dress up anymore. I keep thinking I should, but I want my hubby to dress up with me and he won’t have any part of that idea! I haven’t put on a costume since my 2nd year of college. I wore a men’s suite and an ugly fish tie to a college dance, so it wasn’t much of a costume.

    You’re right, it is probably the most exercise they get. I’m a little appalled when I watch the kids in my neighborhood ride around on motorized scooters all afternoon. When I was a kid I had a scooter and I had to actually push with my foot to move. And if I got tired, I had to try pushing using the opposite leg and that was hard because I was very much “right-footed”.

  5. You remind me… one year I was telling my best friend about the candy I purchased for trickortreaters…
    she asked what kind.
    Something and Smarties… I said excitedly (Obviously I can’t remember the first one all these years later)
    She replied, “Oh. You’re the house with the sucky candy.”

    I LOVE Smarties!!! I thought I was giving the kids a wild treat! I didn’t know it was sucky candy! I swear.
    As a kid, I used to open packets at a time and organize the Smarties by color. I’m a freak.

    However – if we’re worried about childhood obesity — let’s have a bowl of candy and a bowl of coins – and when fat kids come to the door… they get the coins!
    I’m kidding people!

  6. trs: I guess if you were giving out Smarties because you like them that’s acceptable. I know lots of people give them out because they’re cheap.

    I guess if we’re really going to be all out on the childhood obesity thing, we could make obstacle courses to get to the candy. Then every kid would get a little extra exercise. ;-)
    Just to be safe…I’m kidding too!

  7. No that’d be good. It’s goes back to the origination of Trick or Treating. It used to be the kids offered to perform a trick in turn for a treat — or else if you didn’t give them a treat they’d do the trick … like TP your house and lawn.

    But set up an obstacle course and tell them they have to perform the trick before they earn the treat!
    Works for me! Kids that age are supposed to have tons of energy!

  8. Okay.. it isn’t my favorite holiday but I love CANDY! However, I’m one of those people who likes to give out halloween pencils. I think that it is fun to have a pencil that is not the boring kind. (Of course, I give out Candy too!)

  9. I always give out candy that I would want to get. For me, that is usually Raisinettes and Starbursts. Mmm.
    I trickor treated way too old. But no one knew my age, right?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

Gravatar
WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.